A few years ago I sold all my stuff to explore the world, creating 12 startups in 12 months and building $1M+/y companies as an indie maker such as Nomad List and Remote OK. I'm also a big pusher of remote work and async and analyze the effects it has on society. Follow me on Twitter or see my list of posts. My first book MAKE is out now. Contact me
Subscribing you...
Subscribed! Check your inbox to confirm your email.
levels.io

Facebook and Google are building their own cities: the inevitable future of private tech worker towns

Coworking spaces, Future, Tech
Jul 24, 2017

We’re entering a future of tech workers living luxury lives in private cities isolated from the rest of the world, with corporations reaching the levels of power until now only held by cities and nation states. Whether we like that or not, economics states its inevitable. (TL;DR).

This month, Facebook announced they’re expanding their campus in Menlo Park. In corporate lingo they call it “investing in Menlo Park and our community”. But if you read through the lines, it’s a lot more than that. They’re planning building 1,500 houses, with restaurants, a retail shopping area, a giant grocery store, parks, roads and a police station.

Of course, Google followed suit with their own expansion in San Jose

You can call that a campus as much as you want, to me that sounds an awful lot like a city.

“Don’t call it a city though”, Google and Facebook would say. It’s like Uber not wanting to be called a taxi and being regulated. Being called a city means the same. Regulation. Don’t. Call. It. A. City. But it’s a city.

## Trends

This is the start of a trend that’s in turn part of a bigger trend that started about 12 years ago with two things: tech worker campuses and coworking spaces. Famously, Google was the first to introduce playful offices optimized to keep workers happy:

The “serviced” Google office (2005)

They introduced free services for their workers to keep them in the office longer, like free breakfast, lunch, and dinner, free laundry service and free childcare facilities. Suddenly, working for Google became a lot better than working for a regular company. Not just in pay, but in working standards.

Coworking (2005)

At the same time we saw regular companies change too. After the Financial Crisis of 2008 and the economic downturn that took years, massive layoff’s happened. More importantly a cultural shift from employment towards freelancing happened. A lot of people were fired and re-hired as contractors. It was promoted as “flexible work” but the dark side of it was that flexible work has no labor benefits whatsoever. Now outside the office, these freelancers needed places to work: cue coworking spaces:

Nomads (2014)

Then around 2014, we had the explosion of remote work and digital nomads as a big trend. For nomads, coworking spaces offered a place to work but also community away from home:

Coliving (2016)

I said “community”. These remote workers needed places to sleep, so why not sleep near where you work: cue coliving spaces:

In 2016, WeWork, a big coworking provider, introduced WeLive: coliving spaces to live with your “coworkers”. Just like at Google and Facebook, work and private was now mixing in housing facilities.

Meanwhile, with rents in the San Francisco Bay Area rising to unaffordable levels, we saw Google and Facebook start subsidizing rent for their employees. But obviously this was unsustainable.

Private tech workers towns (2021)

It was inevitable. To get better work output, you improve the lives of your workers, well, if you can afford to. And Facebook obviously could by creating its own city. The first part of development will be finished in Menlo Park around 2021.

With Facebook being the biggest employer and investor in Menlo Park in absolute dollar amounts, it’s impossible for Menlo Park to say “no” to these plans. Facebook would simply move to another place, and take its dollars with it. San Jose didn’t even try to stop it and already said overwhelmingly “yes” to Google’s plans:

“Google’s vision of an integrated development in San Jose aligns with the aspirations of the City, transit agencies, surrounding neighborhoods, and downtown businesses for extraordinary architecture, urban design, environmental sustainability, retail amenities, transit ridership and vibrant public spaces,” San Jose Mayor Sam Liccardo, the city’s vice mayor and three other council members wrote in a letter to the San Jose Mercury News daily.

Coliving cities (2020?)

Now what about the freelance tech workers outside Google and Facebook working in coworking spaces and living in coliving spaces? Real estate investors and the hospitality industry are already coworking features into their new projects:

From my inbox: Hotels are opening up in-house coworking spaces (in this case a big luxury chain). Coworking is now a feature, not a product! pic.twitter.com/UokGBLcjrn

— Pieter Levels @ 🇺🇸 (@levelsio) July 20, 2017

And many coworking space owners that I’ve talked to have plans to build coliving towns starting with tens of units, and if successful, quickly expand to hundreds, while attracting local business owners to open up shops, cafes and restaurants in the towns.

Dojo, a coworking space, is rumored to start building the first co-living village in Bali soon.

You can predict this with basic economics, and I’ve discussed it before. Coworking and coliving margins are so tight, the only way to make real money is with vertical integration. That means providing the entire chain of services and products for your user, from breakfast to coworking to coliving to shopping to leisure activities, take 10% from each part in the chain and you have a big business. We’ll see this happen.

History repeats

We’ve seen this before. Actually, a century ago. Philips (and many other industrial giants back then) created its own towns for employees near its factories because it couldn’t get enough (affordable) housing for them. Ironically, that remnants of that town are now used as a space for tech workers.

There’s countless more examples:

In 1893, the chocolate giant Cadbury built a 313-unit village for its factory workers called Bournville. It was built to:

“alleviate the evils of modern, more cramped living conditions”.

Now doesn’t that sound like living conditions in San Francisco and other big cities in 2017? That’s eerily familiar. History repeats if you wait 120 years.

Here’s where it gets scary

The new modern tech worker flies from major city hub to major city hub works for big tech companies (or as a frelancer). And it means, the culture of the 1st-tier cities (NYC, Shanghai) is converging. Meanwhile, the 2nd-tier cities (Dayton, Northampton, Munich) will slowly die out unless they’re near a top-tier city. The top talent work (and pay!) is in the big cities. This is the new reality of urbanism, whether you like it or not.

This means that major cities like New York, Los Angeles, London and Shanghai now essentially have more power in many parts of governing than governments. They’re so big they’ve essentially become small countries of their own. Amsterdam now offers its own expat visa for tech workers to live and work there legally and get a discount on tax. Note: I said Amsterdam, I didn’t say Netherlands. We’re talking a city here. My point exactly.

With corporations starting small towns for their 100,000’s employees (Amazon has 300,000 employees), these may turn into million people cities soon. How? Well, one tech worker probably has a partner at some point, maybe a few kids. That’s an average of 4 dependents per tech worker. 300,000 Amazon employees * 4 dependents = 1,200,000 people in a city. Obviously, this is hypothetical. But we might not be far off.

Let’s continue, hypothetically, if corporations will run million-people cities. And we know big cities are in many ways more powerful than the government. And we know big tech corporations itself are very powerful: Facebook has 2 billion users, that’s 600 million more people than China. Apple holds $256,000,000,000 in cash, or about twice as much cash as the US government. Then combined that might mean big tech corporations will, in the future, have the power of nation states. And will operate like that.

Google already has its own country TLD: .google.

I’m making some big shortcuts here and it’s hypothetical. But if it’s true, I’m not sure we want private entities to run our world.

There’s more to be scared off

Let’s get back to the tech worker cities. Facebook’s plan includes statements like:

We hope to contribute significantly to the housing supply by building 1,500 units of housing on the campus, 15% of which will be offered at below market rates. This added on-site housing should also mitigate traffic impacts from growth. These efforts complement our ongoing work to address the issue, including the Catalyst Housing Fund for affordable housing we established in partnership with community groups to fund affordable housing for our local area. The fund was initiated last year with an initial investment of $18.5 million that we hope will grow.

Obviously, that’s a good step. But it looks more like saving face, you’ll have 85% of rich tech workers and 15% of “non-tech people that can’t afford it”. The reality is that these cities will radically create a division between the rich tech workers and “the rest”.

The reality is that the majority of the world will be left out. Life quality will rise inside the tech worker cities (whether Google/Facebook-ran, or for freelancers), but it will be stagnant or decreasing outside them. That’s quite dystopian.

Why dystopian?

Because put simply: a government’s objective is to increase the life quality of its citizens (at least in theory). A company’s objective is to increase its shareholder’s returns (aka profits). As we know, profits don’t necessarily align with the life quality of (all) people.

As much as we can criticize, that won’t change things. These are inevitable macro-economic forces: fueled by low interest rates that pushed housing prices to unimaginable levels worldwide, failing governments that didn’t build enough housing (and change zoning laws) for all the people moving to the cities, and the automation of work by, well, tech workers, leaving most people with stagnant wages. Nobody will be able to stop any of this. It’s just economics. Nobody, except governments. But if tech companies are more powerful than governments, then, well, what? Exactly.

Basic income? Yes, basic income might help. But whether you get $2,000/month, the division will happen any way.

The future

The future is a tech elite living in their own private tech worker cities. Whether we like it or not.

P.S. I'm on Twitter too if you'd like to follow more of my stories. And I wrote a book called MAKE about building startups without funding. See a list of my stories or contact me. To get an alert when I write a new blog post, you can subscribe below:

Subscribing you...
Subscribed! Check your inbox to confirm your email.

2022
18 Sep
This House Does Not Exist
2022
14 Jul
Sam Parr + Shaan Puri asked me about bootstrapping, open startups and lifestyle inflation (My First Million Podcast)
2022
16 May
Thinking and doing for yourself (Life Done Differently Podcast)
2022
10 May
Relocation of remote workers (Building Remotely Podcast)
2022
26 Jan
Money, happiness and productivity as a solo founder (Indiehackers Podcast)
2022
20 Jan
Bootstrapping, moving to Portugal and setting up Rebase (Wannabe Entrepreneur Podcast)
2021
25 Mar
Why I'm unreachable and maybe you should be too
2021
25 Mar
The next frontier after remote work is async
2021
19 Mar
List of all my projects ever
2021
08 Mar
Why coliving economics still don't make sense
2021
14 Feb
Inflation Chart: the stock market adjusted for the US-dollar money supply
2021
10 Jan
I did a live 4+ hour AMA on Twitch w/ @roxkstar74
2020
20 Dec
No one should ever work
2020
10 Dec
Normalization of non-deviance
2020
05 Dec
Copywriting for entrepreneurs: explain your product how you'd explain it to a friend
2020
30 Nov
Entrepreneurs are the heroes, not the villains
2020
12 Nov
The future of remote work: how the greatest human migration in history will happen in the next ten years
2020
05 Nov
Will millions of remote workers become location independent in 2021?
2020
11 Apr
5 years in startups with Abadesi
2020
11 Jan
Twitter giveaways can be hacked to win every time
2019
16 Oct
Lorn - The Slow Blade ✕ Hong Kong
2019
28 Sep
Most decaf coffee is made from paint stripper
2019
12 Sep
The odds of getting a remote job are less than 1% (because everyone wants one)
2019
08 Sep
In the future writing actual code will be like using a pro DSLR camera, and no code will be like using a smartphone camera
2019
29 Aug
Instead of hiring people, do things yourself to stay relevant
2019
28 Aug
Nobody cares about you after you're dead and the universe destroys itself
2019
28 Aug
The only real validation is people paying for your product
2019
05 Aug
Monitoring Bali's undersea internet cable
2019
29 Jul
Nomad List turns 5
2018
29 Jan
I'm Product Hunt's Maker of the Year again!
2018
28 Jan
Why Korean Jimjilbangs and Japanese Onsens are great
2018
24 Jan
Turning side projects into profitable startups
2018
03 Jan
What I learnt from 100 days of shipping
2017
28 Dec
As decentralized as cryptocurrency is: so will be the people working on it
2017
22 Oct
How to 3d scan any object with just your phone's camera
2017
09 Aug
In a world of outrage, mute words
2017
03 Aug
How to pack for world travel with just a carry-on bag
2017
26 Jul
Building a startup in public: from first line of code to frontpage of Reddit
2017
24 Jul
Facebook and Google are building their own cities: the inevitable future of private tech worker towns
2017
21 Jul
The TL;DR MBA
2017
12 Jul
We did it! Namecheap has introduced 2FA
2017
08 Jun
It's about time for a digital work permit for remote workers
2017
23 May
Using Uptime Robot to build unit tests for the web
2017
08 May
Namecheap still doesn't support 2FA in 2017 (update: they do now!)
2017
03 May
Taipei is boring, and maybe that's not such a bad thing
2017
16 Apr
What we can learn from Stormzy about transparency
2017
17 Feb
The ICANN mafia has taken my site hostage for 2 days now
2017
10 Feb
Most coworking spaces don't make money; here's how they can adapt to survive the future
2017
11 Jan
A society of total automation in which the need to work is replaced with a nomadic life of creative play
2017
07 Jan
Nomad List Founder
2016
12 Dec
Make your own Olark feedback form without Olark
2016
29 Oct
How to fix flying
2016
19 Oct
Robots make mistakes too: How to log your server with push notifications straight to your phone
2016
17 Oct
Hong Kong Express - 上海 (Shanghai)
2016
17 Oct
Choosing entrepreneurship over a corporate career
2016
13 Oct
"I can't buy happiness anymore. I've bought everything that I ever wanted. There's not really anything I want anymore."
2016
11 Oct
From web dev to VR: How to get started with VR development
2016
05 Oct
What I would do if I was 18 now
2016
22 Sep
Bootstrapping Side Projects into Profitable Startups
2016
27 Aug
Kids
2016
13 Aug
How I cured my anxiety (mostly)
2016
26 Jul
We have an epidemic of bad posture
2016
17 Jul
Fixing "Inf and NaN cannot be JSON encoded" in PHP the easy way
2016
26 Jun
My third time in a float tank and practicing visualizing the future
2016
15 Jun
How to add shareable pictures to your website with some PhantomJS magic
2016
29 May
My chatbot gets catcalled
2016
19 May
From web dev to 3d: Learning 3d modeling in a month
2016
09 Mar
My second time in a sensory deprivation chamber
2016
04 Mar
Day 30 of Learning 3d 🎮 Cloning objects 👾👾👾
2016
02 Mar
Day 29 of Learning 3d 🎮 Glass, reflectives, HD, coloring and more details
2016
29 Feb
Day 27 of Learning 3d 🎮 Details, details, DETAILS!
2016
25 Feb
Day 23 of Learning 3d 🎮 Filling up the street and adding shadows
2016
24 Feb
Day 22 of Learning 3d 🎮 Added rain, blinking lights, sound, textured menu sign and a VR web app
2016
23 Feb
Day 21 of Learning 3d 🎮 High res textures, physical rendering and ambient occlusion
2016
22 Feb
Day 20 of Learning 3d 🎮 Objects and camera perspectives 🙆
2016
19 Feb
My first time floating in a sensory deprivation tank ☺️
2016
12 Feb
Day 10 of Learning 3d 🎮 Making complex objects by combining shapes 🙆
2016
06 Feb
Day 4 of Learning 3d: @shoinwolfe visits the actual street I'm modeling 🏮😎🏮
2016
03 Feb
Day 1 of Learning 3d 🎮 I learnt how to make shapes, move, rotate and scale them + how to texturize, and add colored lights 💆
2016
02 Feb
I'm Learning 3d 🎮
2016
27 Jan
The things I have to do to read an email sent to me by my government
2016
12 Jan
How to use your iPhone as a better Apple TV alternative (with VPN)
2015
23 Dec
Here's a crazy idea: automatically pause recurring subscription of users when you detect they aren't actually using your app
2015
17 Dec
Stop calling night owls lazy, we're not
2015
16 Dec
We are the heroes of our own stories
2015
25 Oct
There will be 1 billion digital nomads by 2035
2015
21 Oct
Tobias van Schneider interviewed me about everything
2015
18 Oct
Why doesn't Twitter just asks its users to pay?
2015
17 Oct
Punk died the moment we learnt that the world WAS in fact getting better, not worse
2015
15 Oct
Stop being everyone's friend
2015
14 Oct
Vaporwave is the only music that fits the feeling futuristic Asian mega cities give me
2015
09 Sep
We live in a world built by dead people
2015
01 Sep
Why global roaming data solutions don't make any sense
2015
26 Aug
How to export your Slack's entire archive as HTML message logs
2015
24 Aug
How to play GTA V on your MacBook (and any other PC game)
2015
14 May
I uploaded 4 terabyte over Korea's 4G, and paid $48
2015
08 May
How I sped up Nomad List by 31% with SPDY, CloudFront and PageSpeed
2015
04 May
My weird code commenting style based on HTML tags
2015
01 May
Now is probably the time to make HTTPS the default on all your sites and apps
2015
17 Apr
Do the economics of remote work retreats make any sense?